A WVU art historian's important new book
took years of sleuthing to produce. 

BY TONY COOK

The latest book by the West Virginia University Press demonstrates graphically that there is much more to West Virginia culture than its wonderful folk art and mountaineer lore. Early Art and Artists in West Virginia, by John A. Cuthbert, Ph.D., is a study of the visual-arts side of the state's cultural heritage from the 19th century through the mid-20th century.


"Everything that has happened in American art through the years has also happened in West Virginia," says Patrick Conner, the director of the WVU Press. "This new book is important in helping West Virginia break down the myths about its culture and image."


U.S. Senator John D. Rockefeller IV, a collector of West Virginia art, notes in the book's foreword that "sophistication and elegance have long coexisted with the state's celebrated mountain folk culture." According to Rockefeller, Cuthbert's book is "groundbreaking, because it establishes a foundation upon which we can begin to elaborate the history of art in West Virginia."


From the cover image, a portrait by Berkeley County artist William Robinson Leigh, through the 280 full-color plates inside, the elegantly produced volume presents a sampling of works done by artists who either were both in the state, spent part of their careers here, or who produced West Virginia-inspired works while visiting.


Their works include engravings, illustrations, landscapes, and portraits done in pen and ink, oil on canvas, and watercolors on paper. A carefully researched narrative by Cuthbert places each work in its historical context. The large-format, hardcover book also includes a directory of nearly 1,000 artists who are part of this history.


Cuthbert, an art historian who is the curator of the West Virginia and Regional History Collection at the WVU Libraries, compiled the works over a 17-year period of sleuthing in public and private collections. "Fine art has been here all along," he says, "It's a part of West Virginia's heritage that has been too long ignored."


Decorative and functional items such as pottery and baskets are part of West Virginia's art history, but they are not the only—or even the most important—artistic contributions by the Mountain State to national culture.


Martinsburg's David Hunter Strother was one of the best-known illustrators in America during and after the Civil War. Berkeley County's W.R. Leigh achieved fame as one of the leading artistic interpreters of the American West, and Monongalia County's Blanche Lazzell became one of the 20th century's pioneers of modern art. These artists are joined in lasting greatness by noteworthy artists from other fields, including novelists Pearl Buck and Jayne Anne Phillips in literature, and composer George Crumb and opera performer Phyllis Curtin in music.


"Upstate New York's Hudson River Valley, New Hampshire's White Mountains, and the Delaware Water Gap are all well-known meccas of American landscape painting," Cuthbert notes, "but few people are aware that Harper's Ferry was one of the nation's foremost points of artistic pilgrimage throughout the 19th century." Cuthbert found that nearly a hundred artists visited the town—including leading American artists like Rembrandt Peale, Thomas Doughty, Thomas Anshutz, and Childe Hassam.


The great American landscape painter T. Worthington Whittredge owes his career to the state of West Virginia, according to Cuthbert. Whittredge settled in Charleston to pursue the trade of portrait painting during the early 1840s. Among his clients was the youthful wife of a local politico, "a man of considerable influence in Washington," in the artist's own words. His inability to capture her stunning beauty on canvas, coupled with his growing infatuation for her, led Whittredge to flee the city and the field of portraiture in favor of painting the Kanawha Valley's dramatic scenery. His paintings of the Hawk's Nest area launched his career as one of the 19th century's most celebrated American landscape artists.


The well-known, mid-19th century landscape painter William L. Sonntag also painted extensively in the Kanawha Valley and elsewhere in the state. Sonntag devoted most of the early phase of his career—"arguably his best phase," Cuthbert contends-to painting West Virginia's scenery.


Another discovery was the important connection between Thomas Anshutz and the city of Wheeling. "As the leading teacher of the Ashcan School of American artists, Anshutz was one of the most influential figures in American art history," according to Cuthbert. His best-known work, The Ironworkers' Noontime, is considered to be one of the greatest paintings in American art history: it contributed directly to the development of social realist painting.


The famous work depicts the lunch hour break of laborers at a Wheeling nail factory. Anshutz's mother hailed from Wheeling, and Anshutz visited the city throughout his life, residing there for a period of several years. Cuthbert found numerous sketches and photographs of the Wheeling waterfront area by Anshutz in the Archives of American Art. Included in the group are a series of photos that formed the basis for another of the artist's well-known works, Steamboat on the Ohio.


Cuthbert made discoveries in the field of portraiture as well. By poring over census records and newspaper advertisements, he was able to prove the presence of a number of itinerant portrait "limners" in the Eastern Panhandle in the late and early 19th centuries. He found that the majority of extant works by two of the earliest, John Drinker and David Boudon, depict West Virginia subjects. The only known signed work by Joshua Johnson, America's first African American professional artist, was likely painted in Berkeley Springs. An ad in a Martinsburg newspaper reveals that the well-known Irish-born portraitist John Toole began his career in that area, painting miniature portraits while still in his teens before moving on to have a successful career in eastern Virginia.


Cuthbert's research led to the location and identification of a number of significant works. He found a pair of portraits depicting a youthful Waitman T. Willey, often referred to as the Father of West Virginia, and his wife, in a vacant house near Wellsburg in West Virginia's Northern Panhandle. The pair were painted by the famous Pittsburgh artist David Gilmour Blythe, who visited Morgantown about 1850. An engaging portrait of John Davis at Berkeley Springs, The Bath Keeper by David Hunter Strother, was traced to descendants of the artist residing in a small town in Connecticut. Cuthbert was able to acquire all three works for WVU's West Virginia Historical Art Collection.


Another work, possibly depicting the West Virginia poet Danske Dandridge, was found in an abandoned farmhouse near Middleburg, Virginia. The artist, Shepherdstown native Elezear Hutchinson Miller, was one of the leaders of the Washington, D.C., artistic community during the late 19th century. Today, he is all but forgotten. A tangled web of leads and references eventually led Cuthbert to a Fairfax County, Virginia, woman whose father had purchased several dozen of Miller's works from the artist's estate back in the 1920s.


Miller is a good example of a significant native West Virginia artist who was well known in his own day but who has almost completely faded from memory. Another is Jefferson County's David English Henderson. "Only a handful of Henderson's works are presently known," Cuthbert notes. "Despite the quality of works like his wonderful Halt of the Stonewall Brigade, no one has bothered to undertake a serious study of his career." Such investigations are commonly initiated in the artist's home state, Cuthbert contends, but that has rarely happened in West Virginia.


Part of the problem has rested in the lack of information resources available for the study of West Virginia's art history. Indeed, "one is hard-pressed to find even a good paragraph on the subject," according to Cuthbert.


Until now, that is.


A noted designer of art books, David Alcorn, worked with Cuthbert and Conner at the WVU Press to create the book. Alcorn recalls his experience with the project: "The immediate feeling was that this was going to be a satisfying and successful experience. There are four people in our small book-design firm in California who are quite proud to have been fortunate enough to have participated in bringing this special book to fruition."


Conner is thankful to many people whose assistance is helping make the publication of Early Art and Artists in West Virginia a success: "Senator Rockefeller's support of the project, including providing a foreword, was important. His personal collection of West Virginia art is probably the best outside of our WVU collection. The WVU community has helped in many different ways, from printing to marketing to publicity. Books awaiting sale are warehoused in the new Library Book Depository."


The book is being sold through the WVU Press and the WVU Bookstores for $85 per copy, a price dictated largely by printing and distribution costs. As Cuthbert notes, "This is not a profit-making venture. We hope it will appeal to West Virginians who are interested in their own heritage. It's a history that belongs to all West Virginians."

 

Spring 2001 Contents

Home